Bank Bailouts

“Bailouts incentivize and encourage the financial behavior that makes bailouts necessary.” ~ Holman W. Jenkins, Jr.

The fundamental business model of banking is that the bank accepts money from bank depositors and invest almost all of it. A certain amount of depositors’ money, called reserve requirement, must be kept for redeeming customer accounts and customer withdraws. The remaining deposits gets loaned out, often in long-term illiquid loans  and assets.

If customers want to withdraw amounts greater then the reserves, typically refer to as “ run on a bank”, a bank has two options:

  • Raise money by selling investments at a profit or loss
  • Raise enough money to bridge its cash needs by selling equity in the bank itself hurting shareholders.

Going forward, your bank deposits are implicitly safe from bank failures, but your bank deposits aren’t safe from inflation due to lost of purchasing power, writes Holman W.Jenkins in  WSJ Opinion piece. In essence, the investment risks that large sophisticated uninsured depositors take were shifted to bank shareholders and U.S. taxpayers by the federal government.

Effectively, the FDIC $250K bank deposit insurance limit guarantee is now uncapped. By implicitly guaranteeing all bank deposits, the government’s policy will actually incentivized banks to take even more riskier investment bets with depositers’ cash to garner outsize returns. In short, uninsured deposits were a source of market deposits discipline.

Moral hazard refers to the situation that arises when an individual or bank have the chance to take advantage of a financial deal or situation, knowing that all the risks and fallout will land on another party. It means that one party is open to the option – and therefore the temptation – of taking advantage of another party.

Moral Hazard

In this case, the secondary party, the tax payers, are the ones that suffers all the consequences of any financial risks taken in a moral hazard situation, leaving the first party free to do as they please, without fear of responsibility. They are able to ignore all moral implications and act in a way that is most beneficial to them.

The government’s actions to implicitly guarantee bank deposits does not actually eliminate the risks of additional bank runs or failures, it only transfers the risk and subsequent obligations to the FDIC and ultimately the U.S. taxpayers. It also encourages financial moral hazard, the taking of extraordinary investment risk with bank assets, by bank chief executives.


Source: Holman W. Jenkins, Jr., “Joe Biden’s $19 Trillion Monday”, The Wall Street Journal, March 15, 2023

Duration Risk…What Does It Mean

Duration is a measure of the sensitivity of the price of a bond to a change in interest rates.  Interest rate changes can affect the value of a bank or financial institution’s fixed income (bond) holdings. How a bond or bond portfolio’s value is likely to be impacted by rising or falling interest rates is best measured by duration.  ~ PIMCO

Duration is a measurement of a bond’s interest rate risk that considers a bond’s maturity, yield, coupon and call features. These many factors are calculated into one number that measures how sensitive a bond’s value may be to interest rate changes.

Interest rates may change after you invest in a bond and interest rate changes have a significant impact on bond values. Say you invest in a bond at 5% interest. If interest rates increase by 1%, additional investors in the same bond will now demand a 6% rate of return. Because the bond interest payments are fixed each year, the market price of the bond will decrease to increase the rate of return from 5% to 6%.

The key point to understanding how interest rates and bond prices are related.  It’s important to remember that interest rates and bond prices move in opposite directions. When interest rates rise, prices of traditional bonds fall, and vice versa. So if you own a bond that is paying a 3% interest rate (in other words, yielding 3%) and rates rise, that 3% yield doesn’t look as attractive. It’s lost some appeal (and value) in the marketplace.

Duration is measured in years. Generally, the higher the duration of a bond or a bond fund (meaning the longer you need to wait for the payment of coupons and return of principal), the more its price will drop as interest rates rise.

Duration risk, also known as interest rate risk, is the possibility that changes in borrowing rates (i.e. interest rates) or the Federal Reserve fund rate may reduce or increase the market value of a fixed-income investment.

Generally, the higher a bond’s duration, the more its value will fall as interest rates rise, because when rates go up, bond values fall and vice versa.

If an investor expects interest rates to fall during the course of the time the bond is held, a bond with a longer duration would be appealing because the bond’s value would increase more than comparable bonds with shorter durations.

As you might conclude, the shorter a bond’s duration, the less volatile it is likely to be. For example, a bond with a one-year duration would only lose 1% in value if rates were to rise by 1%. In contrast, a bond with a duration of 10 years would lose 10% if rates were to rise by that same 1%. Conversely, if rates fell by 1%, bonds with a longer duration would gain more while those with a shorter duration would gain less.

% Change in bond prices if rates spike 1%
Hypothetical illustration of the effects of duration, exclusively on bond prices

In summary, bond duration measures the interest rate risk. It is a measure of the change in bond prices due to a change in interest rate. Duration is measured in years. The higher the duration of the bond, the more will be the price drop as interest rates increase. This is because one needs to wait longer to get their coupon payments and principal amount back.

Bond duration is important as it helps in measuring the sensitivity of a bond’s price to interest rates. If the interest rates were to fall by 1% and bond duration is three years, then the price will increase by 3%. This knowledge will help you understand the effect on interest rate changes on the portfolio returns.


References:

  1. https://www.pimco.co.uk/en-gb/resources/education/understanding-duration 
  2. https://scripbox.com/mf/bond-duration/https://scripbox.com/mf/bond-duration/
  3. https://www.blackrock.com/us/individual/education/understanding-duration

Interest Rates, Cost of Capital and Recession

Interest rates are often called the price of money. They determine how expensive capital is to access for companies, but also for individuals and even governments. ~ Jonathan Schramm

The Federal Reserve controls what is called the federal funds rate, which is the rate banks pay to borrow from other banks. Other interest rates throughout the system are based on that rate.

When an economy is in recession or unemployment is high, the Fed lowers rates. This is meant to encourage investment and spending, pushing more money into the economy.

Inflation is a sign there is too much money in the financial system and economy. One way to reduce the monetary supply is to give people and businesses an incentive to take on less debt. A good way to do that is to raise rates. And this is just what the Federal Reserve is doing.

Interest rates affect stocks in two main ways: the impact companies’ bottom line and impact investor’s behavior.

Many companies “roll over” their debt. This means they never really pay their debt, just pay the interest and renew their old bonds with new ones. In this case, rising rates mean the new bonds will cost the company a lot more in interest expenses going forward.

Some companies are also highly reliant on cheap debt to keep afloat or grow. Others rely on customers spending on credit cards. These companies’ profits might suffer in an environment of rising rates.

This is why a rising rate environment favors skilled stock pickers. A solid balance sheet, low debt, cheap valuation, or high profitability will be very valuable in an environment of rising rates.

Higher interest rates are a disincentive for investors to plow borrowed money into asset markets. That’s one of the main reasons why stocks, cryptocurrencies, and other assets crashed in 2022.

Rising rates for borrowed money tends to cause capital flow out of markets, depressing the values of even quality companies. That hurts investors who bought at the top, especially if they bought at the top with borrowed money. For others it creates a valuable entry point.

Overall, rising interests rates and tightening the money supply are a useful tool to help bring inflation under control. But the recent interest rate increase might not have been enough and there’s probably more to come. If inflation stays high, we would need rates continue to rise to curb inflation.

The positive aspects for US investors:

  • Rising rates support a stronger dollar.
  • A strong dollar makes US imports cheaper.
  • A strong dollar support consumers’ spending by decreasing import costs.
  • Rising rates might help to keep inflation under control.

The negative aspects for US investors:

  • Currency devaluation can hurt overseas investments measured in USD.
    Overindebted companies and consumers might not be able to manage higher rates.
  • Rising rates decrease demand for big-ticket items like homes and vehicles.
  • Rising rates increase the risk of a recession.
  • Rising rates make US exporters less competitive.
  • Rising rates restrict the use of borrowed money by investors, decreasing demand for assets across the board.vehicles.
  • Rising rates increase the risk of a recession.
  • Rising rates make US exporters less competitive.
  • Rising rates restrict the use of borrowed money by investors, decreasing demand for assets across the board.

References:

  1. https://finmasters.com/rising-interest-rates-effects/

Inflation is Bad

Inflation is an economic term used to describe rising prices and a loss of purchasing power over time.

Written by Geoff Williams for Forbes Advisor

Inflation is an economic term used to describe rising prices of goods and services, and a loss of purchasing power over time. It occurs when consumers spend more on the same amount of goods and services today than they did a year ago, writes Geoff Williams, a contributor for Forbes Advisor. It is typically expressed as the annual change in prices for everyday goods and services such as food, apparel, transportation and toys.

When everybody pays more and gets less for it, it can have some profoundly devastating effects on the economy—and some consumers get hurt more than others.

“In every economic environment, there are winners and losers and inflation is no exception.  However, the longer high inflation persists, the harder it is to find winners,” says Jeanette Garretty, chief economist at Robertson Stephens, a wealth management firm. “Ultimately, high inflation seeps into the nooks and crannies of every balance sheet and income statement.”

There are three primary types of inflation:

  • Demand-pull inflation
  • Cost-push inflation
  • Built-in inflation

Right now, the country is dealing with all three major types of inflation, which is rare, according to Christopher Blake, assistant professor of economics at Oxford College of Emory University.

Demand-Pull Inflation – Demand-pull inflation describes how demand for goods and services can drive up their prices. If something is in short or disrupted supply, you can generally get people to pay more for it.

The U.S. is experiencing demand-pull inflation due to wages rising and Americans having a decent amount of money in their savings accounts, Blake explains, although some consumers are starting to empty those accounts.

“Consumer spending has remained high, despite the rising prices we currently see,” Blake says. “This is commonly referred to as demand-pull inflation, as consumer demand pulls prices higher because firms cannot keep up.”

Cost-Push Inflation – Cost-push inflation often kicks in when demand-pull inflation is going strong. When raw materials costs increase for businesses, the businesses in turn must raise their prices, regardless of demand.

“Increases to the prices that producers face put businesses in a tough spot,” Blake says. “They can either accept higher costs and keep their prices the same, or they can respond by trying to keep their profit margins the same.”

When the price of chicken keeps going up, for example, eventually your favorite restaurant will need to charge more for a chicken sandwich.

Built-in Inflation – As demand-pull inflation and cost-push inflation occur, employees may start asking employers for a raise. If employers don’t keep their wages competitive, they could end up with a labor shortage.

If a business raises workers’ wages or salaries and tries to maintain profit margins by raising prices, that’s built-in inflation.

Now, if you learn about your favorite coffeehouse raising prices due to the climbing cost of coffee beans, you’re a victim of cost-push inflation.

And if you’re going to buy that coffee even though the price is uncomfortably high, you’re engaging in demand-pull inflation.

3 Ways Inflation Hurts Consumers and the Economy

1. Less Purchasing Power

The most obvious impact of inflation is that it hurts your purchasing power. If you can’t buy as many goods and services as you did before inflation, your quality of living will eventually diminish.

Less purchasing power really hurts families that were already experiencing financial hardship. “Think more money spent on groceries and gasoline, and less spent on travel and entertainment,” says Angelo DeCandia, a professor of business at Touro University.

“Inflation hits the lowest-income families harder because items such as gasoline and food make up a much larger portion of their budgets, leaving less for discretionary spending,” says Dan North, senior economist at trade credit insurer Allianz Trade. “So, for example, where they used to have money to go out to dinner, even fast food, or [go to the] the movies once a month, now they won’t at all.”

A 2021 study from the University of Pennsylvania found that lower-income households had to spend about 7% more on goods and services last year compared to 2019 or 2020, while higher-income households had to spend 6% more. Remember, the annual rate of inflation for 2021 was 4.7%.

2. Less Savings

If rising prices for essentials is eating into your budget more than normal, you probably aren’t putting as much money into a savings account. A June 2022 Forbes Advisor-Ipsos survey found that 42% of respondents were saving less money than usual.

“Inflation makes all of our income and savings less valuable,” says Todd Steen, professor of economics at Hope College in Holland, Michigan.

If you’re not able to save as much as you used to, you may be less prepared for financial emergencies, forcing you to rely on costly credit cards or loans to pay unexpected bills.

And even if you have money in savings already, that decreased purchasing power means your emergency fund might not stretch enough to cover a financial crisis during an inflationary period.

If you have $1,000 socked away for a rainy day, you’re certainly better off than not having it. But here’s an example of how inflation can eat at the value of your savings.

Car repair prices went up 9% from June 2021 to June 2022 according to the CPI. If you had a $900 car repair in June 2021, in June 2022, that same car repair would have been $981. Suddenly your $1,000 saved up is a little less valuable.

“Inflation is a difficult problem to get rid of in an economy, because when prices increase, workers want to have higher wages and salaries to keep up,” he says. “This can lead to future price increases, and the cycle continues.”

3. Loss of Goods and Services

Some industries do pretty well during inflationary times, particularly ones in which you can’t hold off your spending indefinitely, like supermarkets, gas stations and funerals—but some businesses are completely devastated.

That’s because when inflation runs rampant, consumers spend their money on products and services that they absolutely need, and hold back on what they don’t.

You’re going to get your car repaired if you need it. You’ll keep spending money on food.

But you might not take your kids to a trampoline park. You might instead opt for a free city playground with the youngsters, instead. Decisions like that are understandable when prices are high but collectively, they can damage segments of the economy.

“That could mean your favorite pizza place closes, or your nail salon drops a service because it’s become too costly,” says Callie Cox, an investment analyst at eToro.

The renown economist Milton Friedman quipped that inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon in the sense that it is and can be produced
only by a more rapid increase in the quantity of money supply than in output of goods and services. Consequently, empirical evidence suggest that, if growth in the money supply is greater than the actual growth in GDP, inflation results.


References:

  1. https://www.forbes.com/advisor/personal-finance/why-is-inflation-bad/
  2. https://www.nytimes.com/article/inflation-definition.html
  3. https://www.forbes.com/advisor/personal-finance/types-of-inflation/
  4. https://www.caixabankresearch.com/en/economics-markets/inflation/inflation-merely-monetary-phenomenon

Focus, Discipline and Patience are Wealth Building Super Powers!

Are American Consumers in a Recession?

Over the past few months, supply-chain headwinds, inflationary pressures, inverted U.S. Treasury bond yield curve, and rising interest rates has added friction to the U.S. economy and to business operations across industries.

Consequently, investors have become extremely pessimistic about the economic outlook and stock market sentiment, which both are expected to witness a downturn in 2023 amid the impending prospects of a recession.

Per JPMorgan Chase, rising interest rates, record decades high inflation, geopolitical pressure and other factors could lead to a recession that will likely wash away the benefits of savings and the massive government aid received during the pandemic. Moreover, the job market is expected to downshift significantly and unemployment is projected to increase next year as the economy weakens.

A growing number of companies are opting to leave jobs vacant when employees leave or announcing hiring freezes. Widespread layoffs so far have been limited to the handful of industries hammered by rising interest rates, such as technology, housing and finance, say Mark Zandi, chief economist of Moody’s Analytics, and Jim McCoy, senior vice president of talent solutions for ManpowerGroup, a staffing firm.

The Federal Reserve, by increasing its benchmark interest rate to counter inflation, has raised the possibility of a downturn next year. Some experts believe that the Federal Reserve’s bid to contain inflation by increasing interest rate and tightening the money supply will likely achieve its target but put pressure on the consumer’s wallet and potentially trigger a recession in 2023.

Fifty-seven percent of the National Association for Business Economics (NABE) economists see more than a 50% chance of recession next year, according to the results of a new survey published by NABE. The survey pointed to the Federal Reserve’s continued raising the federal funds rate and tightening of monetary policy in an effort to tame inflation as the biggest challenge facing the economy.

Additionally, Gregory Daco, chief economist of EY-Parthenon, expects a recession to hit by the first half of 2023 as hiring slows and layoffs spread across industries, leading to net job losses for the year. He expects the economy to grow just 0.3% for the full year and unemployment to peak at 5.5%.

Many Americans believe that the U.S. economy and the global economy are already in a recession. However, with consistently strong job growth, historically low unemployment and solid growth in consumer spending, that doesn’t sound like a recession most people would remember.

But, a recession is in the eyes of the beholders. Essentially, “It depends on who you ask,” says Capital Group economist Jared Franz. “With food, energy and shelter prices all rising faster than wages, the average American consumer would probably say yes. In my view, we are either on the edge of a recession or we are already tipping into it.”

To put things in perspective, over the past 70 years the average U.S. recession has lasted about 10 months and resulted in a GDP decline of 2.5%. In Franz’s estimation, the next one may be worse than average, if current trends persist, but still less severe than the Great Recession from December 2007 to June 2009.

Key economic indicators point to a potential recession

Sources: Capital Group, Bureau of Economic Analysis, National Bureau of Economic Research, U.S. Department of Commerce.

The official arbiter of U.S. recessions, the National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER) considers many factors beyond GDP, including employment levels, household income and industrial production. Since NBER usually doesn’t reveal its findings until six to nine months after a recession has started, we may not get an official announcement of an economic recession until next year.

“It’s fair to say that most consumers probably don’t care what NBER thinks,” says Capital Group economist Jared Franz. “They see inflation above 9%, sharply higher energy prices and declining home sales. They feel the impact of those data points. The labor market is one of the only data points that isn’t signaling a recession right now.”


References:

  1. https://www.cnbc.com/2022/12/06/recession-walmart-jpmorgan-gm-ceos-talk-about-possible-slowdown.html
  2. https://www.msn.com/en-us/money/markets/is-a-2023-recession-coming-job-growth-likely-to-slow-sharply-companies-brace-for-impact/ar-AA159tMa
  3. https://www.foxbusiness.com/economy/labor-market-may-skirt-us-recession-nabe
  4. https://www.capitalgroup.com/advisor/insights/articles/is-us-already-in-recession.html

Federal Reserve Policy and the Stock Market

“Don’t Fight the Fed” is an old market cliché that was very applicable during the longest bull market in US history. It is also very applicable currently as the Fed implemented policies to slow the economy by raising interest rates and selling assets from its balance sheet. ~ Chris Vermeulen, Seeking Alpha

In 1977, the US Congress officially gave the Federal Reserve a multi-part mandate to maximize employment, maintain prices near an acceptable inflation target of around 2%, and moderate long-term interest rates. In general terms, Fed policies are supposed to stimulate the economy when it’s weak and cool it when it’s too hot.

The adage highlights the strong correlation between Federal Reserve policy and the direction of the stock market.

“Don’t Fight the Fed” embodied the sentiment that if the Fed was stimulating the economy with accommodative policies, it made little sense to bet against the market’s bullish trend. Effectively, when the Federal Reserve’s monetary policy is loose, markets tend to move higher, volatility is subdued, and investors’ risk is limited, so it makes sense to stay invested and ride the wave. Why “fight the Fed” by selling stocks when it’s on your side?

The Fed held interest rates near zero and instituted a policy called quantitative easing—where it bought mortgage-backed securities and U.S. Treasuries to increase the money supply in hopes of spurring lending and capital investment.

When the Federal Reserve is on a mission to slow the economy down in order to tap down inflation, technology and growth stocks are generally hurt as the cost of capital and borrowing money increases. Thus, the old adage, “Don’t fight the Fed” becomes an important one for investors to abide.

With inflation being persistent in the U.S., Fed officials have taken a new monetary stance that is far less appealing for investors.

The Fed is in Quantitative Tightening mode and has raised interest rates and sold assets from its balance sheet. This calendar year, the Fed has raised interest rates four times and has begun shrinking its balance sheet after years of quantitative easing pushed its holdings to nearly $9 trillion. Its intent is to cool the economy and reduce inflation.

The adage, “Don’t fight the Fed”, is a warning to avoid stocks, or at least to take a more conservative approach to investing.

As a result, investors should take a more cautious approach in this tightening environment and prioritize defensive stocks with pristine balance sheets and steady revenue growth that can survive inflationary pressure.

Inflationary economies tend to punish unprofitable technology and growth companies, despite their potential. Without profits or cash flow, it’s simply too hard to improve quarter over quarter at a time when money becomes more expensive to borrow.


References:

  1. https://www.fortunebuilders.com/best-stocks-to-buy/
  2. https://fortune.com/2022/09/14/dont-fight-the-fed-new-meaning-inflation-economy-dan-niles-satori-fund/amp/
  3. https://seekingalpha.com/article/4544537-dont-fight-the-fed

The Impact of Increasing Interest Rates on the Economy and Investing

The Federal Reserve Bank (Fed) implements monetary policy that has a broad impact on the US economy. One of the ways the Fed impacts its dual mandate of managing unemployment and inflation is to periodically raise or lower interest rates.

The Federal Reserve in November 2022 raised interest rates by three-quarters of a percentage point — or 75 basis points — for the fourth time in the calendar year, bringing its key benchmark borrowing rate that rules all other interest rates in the economy up to a target range of 3.75-5 percent, where it hasn’t been since early 2008, according to a Bankrate.

The fed funds rate matters because it has ripple effects on every aspect of consumers’ financial lives, from how much they’re charged to borrow to how much they earn in interest when they save. And, changing interest rates is one of the main tools that the Fed can use to cool down inflation.  

Inflation is the increase in the prices of goods and services over time and occurs when the demand for those goods and services exceeds supply. Inflation also represents a loss of purchasing power.

Typically, the Fed raises interest rates in times of economic expansion and does so to prevent the economy from overheating. The opposite is true when interest rates are cut, which typically occurs when the economy is in a down trend. 

To raise interest rates, the Fed changes the overnight rates at which it lends money to banks. That sets off a chain reaction that impacts the rates banks charge to businesses and individuals. When rates rise, the impact on the economy includes:

  • Borrowing costs rise for businesses, which can reduce investments in new plants, equipment, marketing, and physical expansion.
  • Borrowing costs rise for consumers, which reduces consumer spending, home buying, and investing.
  • Savings accounts and other low-risk investments earn more interest, making investing in low-risk instruments more attractive.

Markets adjust, with fixed income securities generally reducing in value and equities reacting in a mixed fashion depending on how much a rate rise is expected to affect specific types of businesses.

The U.S. Interest Rate Historical Timeline

The chart below shows the history of Fed Funds Rates going back to 1954.

The U.S. Interest Rate Historical Timeline The chart below shows the history of Fed Funds Rates going back to 1954.

Chart of Fed Funds Rate (Macrotrends)

Rising interest rates impact investing in several ways, some of which are fundamental and some of which are perceptual.

Adding to the dilemma for many investors is the inflation outlook and the question of how transitory or persistent that inflation will be. From a rate perspective alone, rising rates can be expected to have the following impact:

  • Prices of bonds and other fixed-income investments will weaken with rising rates, especially the longer-term instruments.
  • Rates offered on new bonds will rise, making them somewhat more competitive with equities.
  • Rates should rise in bank products such as CDs, bringing them back on the radar for investors.
  • When rates rise, stocks tend to fall — when rates fall, stocks rise.

Equity market reactions will be mixed, depending on the effects of higher rates on different companies and industries. Companies that are more leveraged will incur higher costs. Companies with high-ticket products that rely on consumer credit may weaken. On the whole, rising rates should also dampen enthusiasm to speculate, given higher borrowing costs.

“When interest rates are low, companies can assume debt at a low cost, which they may use to add team members or expand into new ventures,” says Brenton Harrison, CFP® professional based in Nashville, TN. “When rates rise, it’s harder for companies to borrow and more costly to manage what debt they already have, which impacts their ability to grow,” he adds. These higher costs may result in lower revenues, thus negatively impacting the value of the company.

Also keep in mind that as rates fall on savings accounts and certificates of deposit, investors generally seek out higher paying investments like stocks and are generally seen as a catalyst for growth in the market; in a rising rate environment investors tend to shift away from stock to places with less risk and safer returns. 

The specter of rising rates can also change the behavior of investors, many of whom may decide to put off purchases on credit or sell stocks that were purchased on margin, based more on their expectations than on near-term reality.

“Central banks tend to focus on fighting the last war,” says Scott Sumner, monetary policy chair at George Mason University’s Mercatus Center. “If you have a lot of inflation, you get a more hawkish stance. If you’ve undershot your inflation target, then the Fed thinks, ‘Well, maybe we should’ve been more expansionary.’”


References:

  1. https://seekingalpha.com/article/4503025-federal-reserve-interest-rate-history
  2. https://www.bankrate.com/banking/federal-reserve/history-of-federal-funds-rate/
  3. https://www.businessinsider.com/personal-finance/how-do-interest-rates-affect-the-stock-market

Monetary Tightening

“We have overstimulated the economy by a big factor” ~ Sam Zell

Billionaire investor Sam Zell told CNBC Squawk Box that he sees no reason to be optimistic that there won’t be further severe economic (recession) and market (bear market) pains. “We have overstimulated the economy by a big factor,” Zell remarked. “We have to take the punch bowl away.”

He thinks a liquidity crisis may be up next and believed the whole “inflation is transitory” political soundbite originating from the Federal Reserve and the Biden Administration several months ago was an embarrassment and the phrase should be relegated to the dust bin of history.

Free money–monetary quantitative easing and historically low interest rates–leads to excess which leads to recession, states Zell. It’s really that simple.

Markets will not bottom until all that excess loose money bleeds out of the economy and Fed tightens its monetary policy. The pain of recession and further market decline are needed and will be good for long term markets.

The Federal Reserve maintained a too loose and easy monetary policy for too long.

“If you get really good at what you do, you get the freedom to be who you really are.” ~ Sam Zell


References:

  1. https://www.costar.com/article/1152237605/real-estate-magnate-sam-zell-moonlights-as-economist
  2. https://www.agriculture.com/news/business/risk-and-reward-a-conversation-with-sam-zell

Sam Zell, founder and chairman of Agricultural Real Estate, used to joke that his father made a life-or-death decision when he was 34 years old, and then never made another mistake again. Zell was inspired by his father’s confidence.

Will Higher Interest Rates Tame Inflation?

Interest rates don’t determine inflation; the amount of money circulating in the economy determines inflation.  At this point, there are over $5 trillion in excess money in the system. Brian Wesbury

While inflation roars at its highest level in four decades, President Joe Biden tried to downplay skyrocketing inflation, insisting it was only up “just an inch” in the short term.

“Well, first of all, let’s put this in perspective. Inflation rate month to month was just– just an inch, hardly at all,” President Joe Biden on Sixty Minutes

Despite the fact that consumer prices rose in August by one-tenth of a percentage point to 8.3 percent, economists had expected inflation to go down. Additionally, median inflation hit the highest level ever recorded.

The median CPI, which excludes all the large changes in either direction and is better predicted by labor market slack, is extremely ugly at 9.2% annual rate in August, the single highest monthly print in their dataset which starts in 1983 (second highest was in June).

The Federal Reserve has been raising interest rates since March to slow the economy in a bid to tame America’s worst bout of inflation in four decades. However, the data suggested that their efforts have not yet had much of an effect.

The Federal Reserve raising interest rates may reduce economic growth, make capital more expensive and may throw the US economy into recession, however there is no guarantee that these actions will tame or fix inflation, opines Brian Wesbury, Chief Economist, First Trust Advisors L. P. Interest rates, supply disruptions or Russian’s war in Ukraine don’t determine inflation; the amount of money circulating in the economy determines inflation.  

“Inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon.” ~ Milton Friedman

The Fed’s balance sheet held $850 billion in reserves at the end of 2007.  Today, the balance sheet is close to $9 trillion.  Most of these deposits at the Fed are bank reserves which the Fed created by buying Treasury bonds, much of which was money the Treasury itself handed out during the pandemic.  At this point, there are over $5 trillion in excess money in the system.

Technically, banks can do whatever they want with these reserves as long as they meet the capital and liquidity ratio requirements set by regulators.

  • They can hold them at the Fed and get the interest rate the Fed sets, or
  • They can lend them out at current market interest rates.  

In turn, the big question is whether the Fed can pay banks enough to stop them from lending in the private marketplace and multiplying the money supply.

The Fed has never tried to stop bank lending in an inflationary environment by just raising the interest rate on excess reserves (IOER). Moreover, the Fed is now losing money on much of its bond portfolio because it bought so many bonds at low interest rates. At some point the Fed will be paying out more in interest than it is earning on its securities.

Inflation is a loss of purchasing power over time, meaning your dollar will not go as far tomorrow as it did today.


References:

  1. https://www.ftportfolios.com/Commentary/EconomicResearch/2022/9/19/will-higher-interest-rates-tame-inflation
  2. https://www.breitbart.com/economy/2022/09/13/underlying-inflation-reaches-scorching-new-record-high/

“Taxes now impose a greater burden on the average American household than the combined cost of food, clothing, education, and health care.”

Federal Reserve Balance Sheet and Inflation

The U.S. Federal Reserve’s balance sheet consists of the Fed’s portfolio of U.S. Treasury and government-guaranteed mortgage-backed securities (MBS).

The balance sheet is one of the Federal Reserve’s main instruments for conducting monetary policy and for fulfilling the Federal Reserve’s dual mandate that requires it to ensure both stable prices and maximum employment.

The traditional tool the Fed used to accomplish these goals was the adjustment of the federal funds rate, the short-term interest rate that determined how much it costs for banks to lend to each other overnight.

The 2007-2008 financial crisis, however, demonstrated that even lowering the interest rate to zero was considered insufficient to shore up economies in freefall, and the Fed turned to more unusual tactics.

One of these measures was what the Fed refers to as “large-scale asset purchases,” which is more commonly known as “quantitative easing.” Just as with any other firm, securities that the Fed purchases through quantitative easing are considered assets and therefore are represented on the Fed’s balance sheet.

The value of the balance sheet of the Federal Reserve increased overall since 2007, when it stood at roughly $0.9 trillion U.S. dollars.

As of September 6, 2022, the Federal Reserve had $8.82 trillion U.S. dollars of assets on its balance sheet.

This dramatic increase can be traced back to two black swan events that had a disastrous impact on the U.S. economy:

  • the 2008 financial crisis and
  • the COVID-19 pandemic,

Both events led to a negative annual growth of the real gross domestic product (GDP) of the United States, writes Thomas Wade is the Director of Financial Services Policy at the American Action Forum. Therefore, the Federal Reserve’s response to these crises was to adopt expansionary monetary policies to stimulate employment and economic growth.

Increasing the money supply — an expansionary monetary policies which intends to increase the amount of money circulating in the economy — tends to increase inflation, states Statista.com, which destabilizes the economy and erodes purchasing power. Currently, the inflation rate in the United States reached 8.5 percent in 2022, the largest value in four decades.

Bottomline is that by expanding its balance sheet—i.e., by buying government bonds and MBS—the Fed expands the nation’s money supply in the hope of lowering interest rates and stimulating the economy; contracting the balance sheet should have the opposite effect.

However, by expanding the money supply too much, the Fed ran the risk of igniting inflation [“Inflation is one form of taxation that can be imposed without legislation.” Milton Friedman], while overly contracting it may stifle economic activity, including increasing unemployment and triggering an economic recession.

Inflation’, quipped Milton Friedman, ‘is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon, in the sense that it cannot occur without a more rapid increase in the quantity of money than in output.

Inflation is a loss of purchasing power over time, meaning your dollar will not go as far tomorrow as it did today.


References:

  1. https://www.statista.com/statistics/1121448/fed-balance-sheet-timeline
  2. https://www.americanactionforum.org/insight/tracker-the-federal-reserves-balance-sheet/#ixzz7esb8x4vu
  3. https://www.fxcm.com/markets/insights/federal-reserve-balance-sheet/